Thaïs at Los Angeles with Domingo and Fournillier

Plácido Domingo offers American audiences his first Athanaël, already successfully honed in Europe, and about which there really is nothing to say or write…or very little.

At 72, the General Director of the Los Angeles Opera, is still, despite everything, a 10, in the vocal and dramatic “force of nature” category! The breath is slightly shorter, the timbre slightly less colored. The movements have slowed down a bit, but this Athanaël, ardent, impassioned, yet vulnerable, and that voice, spontaneous, generous, bronze, enhanced by that elegance, that noble phrasing– all of this grabs the listener and observer from the first notes…because to paraphrase Ernest Newman, who was referring to someone else, “He must be seen to be really heard.”

If you like your Thaïs strong, solid, vigorous, athletic (crossing the desert doesn't bother her at all), then you will appreciate this powerful and profound interpretation by Nino Machaidze (the voice is, nevertheless, light and delicate in the upper register.) Dramatically, however, the acting is simplistic, inadequate, and requires improvement.

The excellent Nicias of Paul Groves, a presence, solid vocally, deftly avoids the traps and pitfalls of the role. Notable too are the fine Palémon of Valentin Anikin, as well as an excellent and convincing Albine (Milena Kitic), not forgetting the celebrated “Meditation,” in context, a true witness to the “transfiguration” of Thaïs (Roberto Cani, solo violin).

Nicola Raab's dazzling production, because it literally dazzles you with its golds, crimsons and purples, is enchanting and persuasive. Johan Engels' sets and costumes plunge us into a world of decorative panels, of posters by Orazi, of course, but also by Muchat or Chéret. In Act II, we are no longer in the realm of Thaïs but rather in that of Loti, the orientalist. Raab's concept, a touch esoteric, does make us think:  Who on earth are those men in top hats and tails in Act III?…and why the wedding gown at the end?…Is it to make us clearly understand that our courtisan has married Christ?… To remind us of Sanderson?

Patrick Fournillier succeeds in being sensual and modest, delicate and discreet, but also energetic and eloquent when necessary.

Photo credit: Thaïs  © Robert Millard / LA Oper

Translated by Miriam Ellis